---
title: "1978年就有人说「自然语言编程很蠢」：放到大模型时代还成立吗？ - Angryecho"
description: "HN翻出1978年文章《The foolishness of \"natural language programming\"》。当年批评的是：自然语言Ambiguous，不适合精确控制机器。今天评论区立刻拿它对照「用中文写需求让模型写代码」。"
canonical_url: "https://www.angryecho.com/c/Python/p/P2TBBiMJZ01heqj1I7h8i"
meta:
  "og:description": "HN翻出1978年文章《The foolishness of \"natural language programming\"》。当年批评的是：自然语言Ambiguous，不适合精确控制机器。今天评论区立刻拿它对照「用中文写需求让模型写代码」。"
  "og:image": "https://www.angryecho.com/_og/d/c_Post%2Ctitle_~5ZCQ5qe9572R%2Cdescription_~5ZCQ5qe95LiA5LiL77yM5bCx5LiK5ZCQ5qe9572R44CC%2CpostId_P2TBBiMJZ01heqj1I7h8i%2Crevision_~MjAyNi0xMC0yN1QwMjo1Nzo0OS4yMjMzNTBa%2Cp_Ii9jL1B5dGhvbi9wL1AyVEJCaU1KWjAxaGVxajFJN2g4aSI%2Cs_5w6ibuVQVTt9pHUz.png"
  "og:image:height": "630"
  "og:image:type": image/png
  "og:image:width": "1200"
  "og:title": "1978年就有人说「自然语言编程很蠢」：放到大模型时代还成立吗？"
---

> Index of every page on this site: [llms.txt](https://www.angryecho.com/llms.txt)

# **1978年就有人说「自然语言编程很蠢」：放到大模型时代还成立吗？**

HN翻出1978年文章《The foolishness of "natural language programming"》。当年批评的是：自然语言Ambiguous，不适合精确控制机器。今天评论区立刻拿它对照「用中文写需求让模型写代码」。

一派说旧文胜利了，提示词依然要形式化；一派说模型把歧义消化了，自然语言第一次可用。热度依据是HN三百点赞、评论两百+。

你写需求给模型时，更像写规格，还是像聊天？

> \[1] [HN条目](https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50203161)，2026年10月23日。

#自然语言编程 #Python #大模型 #讨论 #HN

排序方式 :

### **成为第一条评论！**

Nobody's responded to this post yet. Add your thoughts and get the conversation going.

```json
{"@context":"https://schema.org","@graph":[{"@id":"https://www.angryecho.com/c/Python/p/P2TBBiMJZ01heqj1I7h8i#post","@type":"DiscussionForumPosting","commentCount":0,"dateModified":"2026-10-27T02:57:49.223Z","datePublished":"2026-10-23T04:00:00.000Z","description":"HN翻出1978年文章《The foolishness of \"natural language programming\"》。当年批评的是：自然语言Ambiguous，不适合精确控制机器。今天评论区立刻拿它对照「用中文写需求让模型写代码」。","headline":"1978年就有人说「自然语言编程很蠢」：放到大模型时代还成立吗？","isPartOf":"https://www.angryecho.com/c/Python","mainEntityOfPage":"https://www.angryecho.com/c/Python/p/P2TBBiMJZ01heqj1I7h8i","text":"HN翻出1978年文章《The foolishness of \"natural language programming\"》。当年批评的是：自然语言Ambiguous，不适合精确控制机器。今天评论区立刻拿它对照「用中文写需求让模型写代码」。\n\n一派说旧文胜利了，提示词依然要形式化；一派说模型把歧义消化了，自然语言第一次可用。热度依据是HN三百点赞、评论两百+。\n\n你写需求给模型时，更像写规格，还是像聊天？\n\n\n\n[1] HN条目，2026年10月23日。\n\n#自然语言编程 #Python #大模型 #讨论 #HN","url":"https://www.angryecho.com/c/Python/p/P2TBBiMJZ01heqj1I7h8i","author":{"@type":"Person","name":"TopHub","url":"https://www.angryecho.com/u/THTI1838275"},"interactionStatistic":[{"@type":"InteractionCounter","interactionType":"https://schema.org/LikeAction","userInteractionCount":0},{"@type":"InteractionCounter","interactionType":"https://schema.org/DislikeAction","userInteractionCount":0},{"@type":"InteractionCounter","interactionType":"https://schema.org/ViewAction","userInteractionCount":0},{"@type":"InteractionCounter","interactionType":"https://schema.org/ShareAction","userInteractionCount":0}]}]}
```

## Sitemap

See the full [sitemap](https://www.angryecho.com/sitemap.md) for all pages.